Tag: Madoff

  • Madoff to face his victims in court Thursday

    This is the week that Bernard Madoff, the former NASDAQ chairman accused of perpetrating the biggest fraud in U.S. history, will confront his victims for the first time – and perhaps even acknowledge his own culpability.

    On Thursday, at the second of two court hearings this week, the 70-year-old will come face to face with some swindled investors who until now, have had no place to air their fury and devastation.

    Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

    Click to activate this MucketyMap

    Click to activate interactive map
    (requires Java)
    MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

    If that’s not drama enough, it’s also when Madoff may plead guilty.

    Last week, the trader waived his right to have a grand jury review the charges against him, setting the stage for a possible guilty plea Criminal-defense experts say a trial is unlikely in cases where prosecutors don’t seek a grand-jury indictment.

    Should Madoff enter a guilty plea this week, it would be turned inside out for clues as to whether his wife, sons or business associates may also face prosecution. If, for instance, he tells the court that other people ‘known and unknown’ were involved in the fraud, that would increase their exposure.

    Likewise, should he be charged with, or plead guilty to conspiracy, that would suggest that prosecutors plan to go after others, former federal prosecutor Steven Frankel told Newsday.

    After his arrest Dec. 11, Madoff told authorities he acted alone in setting up a Ponzi scheme said to have involved tens of billions of dollars. But many have expressed skepticism that he could have pulled off a fraud on that scale without the notice, if not the assistance of others.

    As for Madoff’s possible prison term , that would be a function of the crimes to which he pleads.

    The charges are expected to include securities fraud, mail and wire fraud, and money laundering, Newsday reported. Securities fraud alone carries a maximum sentence of 25 years.

    Federal prosecutors have also signaled they intend to go after Madoff’s assets, and filings indicate they will challenge defense attorney Ira Sorkin’s claim that Ruth Madoff should be entitled to keep $62 million in assets, in addition to their penthouse Manhattan apartment, valued at $7 million.

    It’s not clear how many investors might attend the court hearing after U.S. District Judge Denny Chin invited victims late Friday to address the court.

    Chin’s invitation was in response to papers filed by prosecutors asserting that victims had the right to be “reasonably heard at any public proceeding in the district court involving release, plea, sentencing, or any parole proceeding.”

    Thousands lost money, among them many charitable institutions and schools. Prosecutors have asked anyone wishing to be heard to send an e-mail to usanys.madoff@usdoj.gov. by 10 a.m. Wednesday.

    “There will be some fireworks,” Brad Friedman, a New York lawyer representing dozens of people who lost hundreds of millions of dollars, told the Associated Press. “But it’s not going to be blistering because it’s a courtroom. People will stand up in a respectful but forceful manner.”

    Friedman said none of his clients have asked to attend next week’s hearing, and he’d advise them not to go.
    “I just don’t think it accomplishes a lot,” he said. “You’re not going to make him feel bad.”

    Madoff is also scheduled to appear in court Tuesday when the judge to explore whether there is a conflict of interest involving defense attorney Ira Sorkin. Sorkin’s now-deceased father had an account with Madoff, and in 1992 the lawyer represented a Florida investment firm, Avellino & Bienes, that invested with Madoff.

    Madoff is expected to tell the court he understands the potential conflicts and has decided to stick with Sorkin anyway, according to people familiar with the case.

    Click here to sign up for the Muckety Newsletter




    Follow Muckety on Twitter


    Muckety's Facebook page


    This post is tagged with: , , , , ,
     Read related stories: Recent Stories  

    1 Comments

    • #1.   agilog 03.09.2009

      Let’s bring back the stockade for criminals like Madoff.
      Good idea or cruel and unusual?

    Leave a Comment


    • Prince Charles burnishes green credentials

      March 11, 2009 at 4:51pm

      Call him the Green Prince. Britain’s heir apparent is on a 10-day tour of Latin America to promote measures to combat climate change – and to raise his profile as a national ambassador.

    • Ruth Madoff seeks to keep NY penthouse, $62M in assets

      The wife of accused swindler Bernard Madoff is arguing that their $7 million Manhattan penthouse and an additional $62 million in assets belong to her.

      In court papers filed Monday in U.S. District Court in Manhattan, Ruth Madoff and her lawyer claim that the Upper East Side apartment, $45 million in municipal bonds and $17 million more in a separate account, all belong to her, rather than to her husband, who was charged with a $50 billion scheme to defraud investors.

      Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

      Click to activate this MucketyMap

      Click to activate interactive map
      (requires Java)
      MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

      The bonds, in a Cohmad Securities account held by Ruth Madoff, and about $17 million held by her in a Wachovia Bank account, “are unrelated to the fraud, according to the papers.

      The papers were filed in connection with a U.S. District Court judge’s order Monday to partially lift a freeze on Madoff’s assets so that he could cooperate with a court-appointed trustee overseeing the liquidation of his firm to recover money for bilked investors.

      To date, the trustee has said the Manhattan penthouse apartment and other properties in Montauk, N.Y. and Palm Beach, FL, which were used to secure Bernard Madoff’s bail, were off limits. But if there’s a conviction, those assets might be seized to help pay victims’ claims.

      “We are looking at every member of the Madoff family,” David Sheen, an attorney representing the trustee said regarding the personal property.

      Cohmad Securities, where Ruth Madoff says her account holds municipal bonds, had an office in Madoff’s headquarters in midtown Manhattan. The firm was part-owned by Bernard Madoff and has been alleged by the Massachusetts Securities Division to be a “feeder fund” to his investment firm.

      Last month, Massachusetts regulators said Ruth Madoff withdrew $15.5 million from Cohmad Securities in November and December, including $10 million on the eve of her husband’s arrest for securities fraud.

      She has not been charged with any wrongdoing, however, and is represented by the same attorney as her husband.

      Bernard Madoff was arrested Dec. 11 and charged with securities fraud after authorities said that he confessed to his sons that he had carried out a Ponzi scheme for years, using new money from investors to pay off early investors, while issuing bogus statements claiming investment gains. He has been under house arrest in their Manhattan apartment.

      Click here to sign up for the Muckety Newsletter



       Read related stories: Madoff · Recent Stories  

      1 Comments

      • #1.   Alison 03.03.2009

        She does not deserve ANY of the money or properties unless she can prove beyond a shadow of doubt that it belongs to her and did not come from her husband or one of his numerous companies, which she probably can’t. of course she is one of the rich so normal rules do not apply.
        If I had stolen lets say about $100,000.00 from my bosses and clients, would I be allowed to stay home? no my butt would be in jail so fast..
        on the TV today, it was mentioned that Barack Obama is trying to get rid of prosperity… let me tell you prosperity is not 2% of the population making more money than they can EVER spend and the rest of us watching them complain about their lot in life. I am hopeful that his efforts will be successful but even if he fails, at least he tried to do something!! remember the last guy?!? seemed to spend most of his time with his head up his butt, telling everyone that thing were going well….

      Leave a Comment


      • FCC pick Genachowski is longtime Obama friend, adviser

        March 4, 2009 at 6:04pm

        He is a law school friend of Obama’s and a successful, high-tech entrepreneur who looks to expand broadband service to rural and underserved areas, and to promote an open Internet and diverse media ownership.

      • ‘Bag Lady’ Penney spins Madoff losses into gold

        The Bag Lady may get to keep her expensive jewelry and her West Palm Beach cottage after all.

        Alexandra Penney, the former editor-in-chief of Self magazine who has written about her travails as a rich-girl victim of Bernard Madoff’s in a blog called The Bag Lady Papers may have found a path out of penury.

        Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

        Click to activate this MucketyMap

        Click to activate interactive map
        (requires Java)
        MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

        Penny will receive “a nice sum of money” from Hyperion Books to write about her experience being swindled of her life savings by Madoff.

        While her first-hand account of her financial devastation on Tina Brown’s Daily Beast website (”yesterday, I took my first subway ride in 30 years” ) exasperated some readers, it struck a chord with editors at Hyperion who apparently share some of her fears (”How am I going to iron those shirts [without Yolanda the maid] so I can still feel like a poor civilized person?”).

        Hyperion Publisher Ellen Archer acknowledges that Penney’s blog resonated deeply with her.

        “There are a lot of us, even those of us with paychecks, who are worried that we can end up on the streets,” Archer said. “Even those of us who haven’t invested with Bernie Madoff have taken a lot of financial hits and watching her navigate these difficult waters provides a lot of people with reassurance.”

        To be fair to Penney, she does not pull any punches. She writes of growing up privileged – her mother was Greek royalty, her father was a Harvard lawyer – in “a WASPy Connecticut suburb.” But after leaving her husband, she says she made her own way, primarily by writing bestsellers such as How to Make Love to a Man.

        Despite that success, she was haunted by the fear she would end up a bag lady on the streets – and after confiding that to a friend, got turned onto Madoff as a sort of financial insurance policy. Until the devastasting news of Madoff’s arrest on Dec. 11, that had seemed to be working for her. She was living as an artist with her own New York studio, doing the work she loved and, yes, diniing at the Four Seasons whenever she felt like it.

        Now, thanks to her old network in publishing – and her resolve to go back to writing for a living – she may get to keep Yolanda the maid to iron all those shirts.

        Click here to sign up for the Muckety Newsletter



         Read related stories: Madoff · Recent Stories  

        1 Comments

        • #1.   belles 02.12.2009

          There is a proverb in Japan that states “Nanakorobi Yaoki”.
          Nana = Seven
          Korubi = Fall Down
          Ya = Eight
          Oki = Stand Up
          The proverb translates to, “Seven times down, eight times up”. It derives its origins from okiagari dolls, paper-mache toys than when knocked down, always return to an upright position. The dolls have no arms or legs and are also known as Daruma dolls.
          Daruma (also known as Bodhidharma) was the first patriarch of Zen. He traveled from India to China in the sixth century. Legend has it that he sat in a cave meditating for nine years without moving, in order to obtain enlightenment. In the process, his legs withered to nothing and his hands shriveled away from lack of use. But he remained steadfast and seemed to get healthier with the passing years. Folklore suggests he finally died after vitally living eight hundred thirteen years.
          The armless, legless Daruma dolls are weighted so they always pop up after being pushed down. They represent the resiliency and perseverance of Daruma. They stand for success after misfortune. Daruma dolls inspire you to rise no matter how many times you stumble or fall down. “Nana” in Japanese has a double meaning. It means “seven” but is also used to denote “many”.
          So, “Nanakorobi Yaoki”, or “Seven times down, eight times up”, is a call to never give up. It is a celebration of your spirit, determination, and ability to not only land on your feet, but to also evolve, enjoy, and thrive.

        Leave a Comment


        • Feds probe firms close to Rep. John Murtha

          February 13, 2009 at 10:46am

          Another possible pay-to-play arrangement appears to be unraveling under public scrutiny – this one involving Rep. John Murtha, the powerful defense appropriator from Pennsylvania.

        • Ruth Madoff withdrew $15M before husband’s arrest

          The wife of accused Wall Street swindler Bernard Madoff pulled millions out of a brokerage account only days before her husband was charged with securities fraud – including $10 million on the eve of his arrest, Massachusetts’ top securities regulator said Wednesday.

          Massachusetts Secretary of State William Galvin said Ruth Madoff withdrew $5.5 million on Nov. 25 and $10 million on Dec. 10, according to reports produced by Cohmad Securities, a firm co-owned by her husband.

          Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

          Click to activate this MucketyMap

          Click to activate interactive map
          (requires Java)
          MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

          Ruth Madoff’s role in her husband’s alleged $50 billion Ponzi scheme has been a subject of much debate. To date, she has not been charged with any crime, and though she currently lives with her husband, who is under house arrest in their Upper East Side penthouse, she can come and go as she pleases.

          Attorney Ira Sorkin, who represents both Madoffs, has said the financier admitted to his wife and their two sons only on Dec. 10 that his multibillion-dollar hedge fund was an elaborate Ponzi scheme. The 70-year-old mogul was arrested and charged with securities fraud on Dec. 11. Madoff told authorities he acted alone in confessing to the fraud, prosecutors have said.

          But the revelation of Ruth Madoff’s withdrawals raises fresh questions about what she knew and when she knew it.

          The information about her withdrawals was made public today as part of a lawsuit that Calvin brought against Cohmad Securities in an effort to revoke its Massachusetts brokerage license.

          For years, Cohmad Securities, partly owned by Madoff, was a major conduit into his Ponzi scheme and received monthly payments from him for “professional services”, “brokerage services” and “fees for account supervision,” Galvin’s office said.

          The payments totaled $67 million and made up 84 percent of Cohmad’s total income over the last eight years, the documents show.

          That sum does not include commissions paid to broker Robert M. Jaffe, according to the complaint, because Cohmad did not respond to requests for that information.

          Jaffe – a member of the wealthy Shapiro clan, major philanthropic donors in Boston and Palm Beach, Fla. – appeared under subpoena before Massachusetts regulators last week, but invoked his rights under the Fifth Amendment, declining to answer questions about his business, Cohmad, or his connection to Madoff Investments, according to the complaint.

          Click here to sign up for the Muckety Newsletter



           Read related stories: Madoff · Recent Stories  

          1 Comments

          • #1.   LT 02.12.2009

            That’s right – follow the money – doesn’t it make you wonder how much money Ellen Jafee, wife of Robert Jaffee, withdrew in the days leading up to the Madoff confession? How about withdrawals by the wife of the head of Fairfield Securities in Conn?

          Leave a Comment


          • Judd Gregg withdraws as commerce secretary nominee

            February 12, 2009 at 5:23pm

            Republican Sen. Judd Gregg of New Hampshire withdrew his nomination as commerce secretary Thursday, citing “irresolvable conflicts” with President Barack Obama over his stimulus plan and handling of the 2010 census.

          • Cohmad Securities, Robert Jaffe face tough questions about Madoff ties

            Investigators probing Bernard Madoff’s alleged $50-billion scheme are looking at the role played by an investment firm that he co-founded with an old friend from Long Island that recruited hundreds of investors from New York, Boston and Florida.

            Cohmad Securities and its vice president, Robert Jaffe of Palm Beach and Boston, have already been subpoenaed by Massachusetts regulators in connection with the federal investigation of Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities.

            Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

            Click to activate this MucketyMap

            Click to activate interactive map
            (requires Java)
            MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

            The company, which seemed to function almost as a Madoff subsidiary, was founded by Madoff and his friend and former neighbor, Maurice “Sonny” Cohn, a little more than two decades ago. Cohmad – a name fashioned out of the first three letters of Cohn and Madoff – had its New York offices in the same midtown Manhattan building as Madoff’s investment firm.

            Cohn, a benefactor of Long Island’s North Shore-Long Island Jewish Health System, owns about 80 percent of Cohmad, according to the Wall Street Journal; Madoff is a minority stakeholder, along with Cohn’s daughter, Marcia, and Madoff’s brother, Peter.

            Another stakeholder is Jaffe, a debonair philanthropist who helped recruit dozens of investors from his stomping grounds around the Palm Beach Country Club and the suburbs of Boston.

            Jaffe, who is listed as Cohmad’s vice president, has another major tie to Madoff: He is married to Ellen Shapiro Jaffe, daughter of 95-year-old apparel mogul Carl Shapiro, a decades-old friend of Madoff’s who was one of his earliest and largest investors. By the end, Shapiro is said to have had $545 million with Madoff.

            It’s a strange turnabout for Jaffe, a 64-year-old bon vivant who was sought out in Palm Beach high society, at least in part because he could deliver access to Madoff whose legendary fund guaranteed steady, if unremarkable returns.

            A champion golfer with multiple country club memberships, Jaffe seems to have done many of his deals on the golf course or on the party circuit.

            He is also a fixture of the philanthropic worlds of both Palm Beach and Boston, where he rubbed shoulders with prospective investors on boards ranging from the Palm HealthCare Foundation, which he chairs, to the American Cancer Society’s Palm Beach chapter to Boston’s Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center.

            “He was a very fastidious dresser. Never had a hair out of place,” Richard Rampell, a Palm Beach accountant told Reuters. “He stands ram-rod straight and has sort of a dashing presence,” Rampell added, likening him to characters found in novels by F. Scott Fitzgerald, author of The Great Gatsby.

            But if Jaffe helped Madoff recruit an ever-expanding list of high-net-worth clients, he is now a target of fury.

            At the ritzy Mar-a-Lago Club, an angry investor who lost millions with Madoff confronted Jaffe at a party last month. His son’s engagement party at the Palm Beach Country Club was abruptly canceled. And after he failed to show up for an interview with Massachusetts regulators Tuesday, the secretary of state filed suit to force Jaffe to testify.

            A spokesman for Jaffe said he is under a “doctor’s care” and that he had no knowledge of the alleged fraud and was a victim himself.

            “Was he out selling Madoff? Yes. Did he use his contacts to sell the product? Yes. But he’s as much a victim,” Lawrence Sperber, a Boston lawyer who has a home in Palm Beach and has known Jaffe for more than 40 years, told the Boston Globe. “I don’t think he had any idea. And he’s messed up his relationship with the rest of the world.”

            Cohmad’s filings show that the company, which had fewer than 650 client accounts, made 99.7% of its sales from brokerage services to Madoff’s larger broker-dealer, according to the Journal.

            In its audited financial statements for the 12 months ending June 30, 2008, Cohmad said revenue from Madoff Securities totalled $3,736,829. Its total sales for the same period were $3,748,397.

            Steven Paradise, a Vinson & Elkins lawyer representing Sonny and Marcia Cohn, denied that either of them knew of the alleged fraud or solicited investors for Madoff – and that both had lost money with him. “To the extent Mr. Jaffe was soliciting investors for Madoff, he was not doing so through or for Cohmad,” he said, adding that Cohmad paid rent to Madoff to lease its space.

            Madoff, 70, was charged Dec. 11 with securities fraud for allegedly running a Ponzi scheme — paying one set of investors with money from another. He is free on $10 million bail, pending trial.

            Click here to sign up for the Muckety Newsletter



             Read related stories: Madoff · News · Recent Stories  

            0 Comments

            • There are no comments yet, be the first by filling in the form below.

            Leave a Comment


            • Apple’s Timothy Cook steps up – again

              January 16, 2009 at 11:14am

              The news that Steve Jobs will be taking medical leave from Apple Inc. has once again thrust Timothy D. Cook, Apple chief operating officer, onto center stage.

            • Are Madoff’s attorneys cutting a deal?

              Bernard Madoff may be negotiating a guilty plea.

              Federal prosecutors acknowledged in a court order released Monday that Madoff’s lawyer, Ira Sorkin, is “engaging in discussions concerning a possible disposition of this case,” the New York Times reports.

              Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

              Click to activate this MucketyMap

              Click to activate interactive map
              (requires Java)
              MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

              On the one hand, a negotiated plea deal would deny defrauded investors (and everyone else) the satisfaction of watching the alleged swindler put on public trial. But it may be the only way that the 70-year-old Madoff might get a break and avoid dying in prison, particularly if he cooperates against others or helps recover billions in investor funds.

              Sorkin declined to discuss his strategy but several former prosecutors told the Times that the language indicated that the discussions were about a deal in which Madoff would agree to plead guilty in exchange for some type of leniency.

              “He’s trying to cut a deal,” said Marvin G. Pickholz, a former securities regulator. “The only other possible ‘disposition’ that could be negotiated would be for the government to drop the whole case – and that’s not going to happen.”

              However, Newsday’s Anthony Destefano cited an unnamed source saying that any discussions were in the early stages and that no plea deal was imminent.

              The information about the discussions was contained in an order, signed by the U.S. Magistrate Ronald L. Ellis, that approved a 30-day delay in a hearing on Madoff’s case. That order also denied prosecutors’ request that Madoff be jailed until he can be tried because they deem him a flight risk. Prosecutors said they plan to appeal.

              The judge’s ruling allows Madoff to remain free in his Manhattan penthouse, wearing an electronic monitoring device and being watched by a security team paid for by his wife.

              Ellis wrote that he was not satisfied that the government had proved “by clear and convincing evidence” that jailing Madoff was necessary to ensure he did not flee or obstruct justice. He added several requirements to the bail conditions, among them, requiring Madoff to compile an inventory of all “valuable portable items” in his Manhattan apartment.

              A security firm that is already watching him around the clock will be required to check that inventory every two weeks.

              Madoff was arrested Dec. 11 and charged with one count of securities fraud, but he has not yet been indicted.

              Under federal court rules, Monday would have been the deadline for a hearing at which the prosecution would have had to show “probable cause” for Madoff’s arrest. But both sides agreed to postpone that deadline for at least a month – an indication that discussions about a possible plea deal are taking place.

              Click here to sign up for the Muckety Newsletter



               Read related stories: Madoff · News · Recent Stories  

              2 Comments

              • #1.   Elaine Meinel Supkis 01.13.2009

                The Tribe will protect this guy? HAHAHA. I would think, they should feed him to the wolves. But I suppose, once he has bribed most politicians, they stay bought no matter what. Ask Marc Rich about this!

                A guy in California who steals a pizza can go to prison for life with the three strikes and you are in laws. While a rich man can bribe politicians, break many laws, destroy the entire economic/financial systems of the world and pull the biggest heist in history…and stay home in his expensive pad, trying to mail jewelry to friends?

                But then, Bush and Cheney could get away with committing vast war crimes and killing millions of people so I suppose, we have to keep things in perspective. Arrest them all!

              • #2.   TACOM 01.15.2009

                Justice for the rich and justice for the poor==Amerikka, you gotta love it. Bernie has to tell us where he hid 50 billion. It’s impossible to hide 50 million much less 50 billlion! Did some of it find its way to the Middle East Bernie?

              Leave a Comment


              • Apple’s Timothy Cook steps up – again

                January 16, 2009 at 11:14am

                The news that Steve Jobs will be taking medical leave from Apple Inc. has once again thrust Timothy D. Cook, Apple chief operating officer, onto center stage.

              • After years of complaints about Madoff, Harry Markopolos is vindicated

                Harry Markopolos is being called the Deep Throat of the Bernard Madoff scam. He describes himself as “the boy who cried wolf.”

                In his case, the wolf was real, and no matter how many times Markopolos cried out, the Securities and Exchange Commission did little.

                Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

                Click to activate this MucketyMap

                Click to activate interactive map
                (requires Java)
                MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

                Not until his sons turned him in was Bernard Madoff arrested on charges of conducting a $50 billion swindle defrauding banks, hedge funds, nonprofits and individual investors worldwide.

                In the succeeding weeks, Markopolos, a former investment officer with Rampart Investment, has become known as a financial Cassandra for his repeated warnings about Madoff’s operations.

                He began complaining years ago, his insights culminating in May 2005, with what financial writer Michael Lewis and hedge fund manager David Einhorn described in the New York Times Saturday as a “devastatingly persuasive 17-page letter” to the SEC.

                Either Madoff was front-running customer orders – essentially taking orders, assigning winners to the Madoff company portfolio and passing losing investmens to the customer.

                Or Madoff was conducting what Markopolos labelled “the world’s largest Ponzi scheme.” It appears that scenario two, which Markopolos described as “highly likely” was Madoff’s mode of operation.

                Markopolos used mathematics to dissect Madoff’s investment strategy, and concluded that it couldn’t possibly work. He also questioned the secrecy surrounding the Madoff operation.

                “Only Madoff family members are privy to the investment strategy,” he noted in his 2005 letter to the SEC. “Name one other prominent multi-billion dollar hedge fund that doesn’t have outside, non-family professionals involved in the investment process. You can’t because there aren’t any.

                “…Either (Bernard Madoff) is the world’s best stock and options manager that the SEC and the investing public has never heard of or he’s a fraud.”

                The SEC did follow up on Markopolos’ tips, investigating Madoff, but it found no evidence of front running or of a Ponzi scheme. It found a few technical violations, which Madoff reportedly corrected.

                In his 2005 letter, Markopolos predicted the likely fallout if Madoff Investments turned out to be a Ponzi scheme, likening it to a category 2-3 hurricane. The storm, he said, would include panic selling, implosion of hedge funds and damage to European markets because of the number of French and Swiss banks investing in Madoff.

                There’s a slight trace of crackpot in Markopolos’ writing style. Indeed, there was so much money to go around in the boom years that few but the eccentrics complained. And few regulators paid any attention.

                However, Markopolos backed up his claims with facts and he took care to mention a May 2001 Barron’s article by reporter Erin E. Arvedlund that raised questions about Madoff’s secretive investment methods.

                He also cited a variety of off-the-record financial community sources who reportedly had steered clear of Madoff.

                “I kept firing bigger and bigger bullets but I couldn’t stop him,” he told the Wall Street Journal. His frustration finally ended with Madoff’s arrest on Dec. 18.

                Muckety writer A. James Memmott contributed to this story.

                Click here to sign up for the Muckety Newsletter



                This post is tagged with: , , ,
                 Read related stories: Madoff · Recent Stories  

                0 Comments

                • There are no comments yet, be the first by filling in the form below.

                Leave a Comment