Category: Politics

  • Hillary Rodham Clinton took wrong turn on message, advisers

    The second guessing has begun in earnest.

    Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

    MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

    With Sen. Barack Obama of Illinois having locked up the Democratic presidential nomination, analysts are already working hard to figure out not so much how he won, but how New York Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton lost.

    Jackie Calmes of The Wall Street Journal and Rick Klein of ABC News have rolled out detailed look-backs at the 17-month Clinton campaign and pinpointed several factors that took Clinton from odds-on favorite to second-place finisher.

    In brief, Clinton may have depended upon too small a group of advisers, a group that may have been too confident in the beginning and too grounded in old politics.

    Beyond that, it may have wasted Clinton’s main strength, her ground-breaking appeal as a woman running for what has forever been a man’s job.

    One of the Clinton’s main problems, Calmes suggests, was her “inner circle of two,” her husband, former President Bill Clinton, and her pollster and chief strategist, Mark Penn.

    “Once known for his sunny optimism, Mr. Clinton became a finger-wagging scourge against media bias and Sen. Obama,” Calmes writes.

    Bill Clinton’s made-for-You Tube moments, proved to be a distraction that raised a key issue.

    “If she can’t control her husband in the campaign, who the h— is really going to run the White House,” an adviser asked.

    Penn was reportedly a different kind of problem, numbers obsessed, but awkward with people, someone who seemed to underestimate the fact that voters wanted a change.

    Clinton was an ideal change candidate as she sought to become the first woman president, Klein and Calmes write.

    However, she ran as the candidate of experience, stressing her many years of preparation for the presidency. Following Penn’s advice, she played down her softer side. “Being human is overrated,” Penn allegedly said.

    Penn and Clinton’ other advisers also helped shape a strategy that backfired.

    The Clinton camp didn’t organize fully for the caucus states, believing that the senator would secure the nomination with the votes in big, non-caucus states. Obama’s strategists, on the other hand, put a full-court press on the caucuses and significantly added to their delegate count.

    Eventually, Penn was let go from his campaign leadership position because of day job as a lobbyist. But he remained in contact with the Clintons, and the campaign still reportedly owes him $10 million for his polling.

    And speaking of money: As Klein reports, Clinton’s campaign got off to a better fund-raising start, rounding up the usual donors and getting them and their friends to write $2,300 checks (the maximum contribution for a primary).

    But eventually, that group got tapped out. The Obama campaign caught up and then went past the Clinton campaign, depending on an ever-growing base of small donors.

    Money, momentum and message had all turned Obama’s way and Clinton could not stop the tide. “The bottom line is this,” Calmes writes, fixing the last bit of blame. “Sen. Clinton called the biggest plays, and she got them wrong.”

  • Obama pays homage to ‘Toot,’ his grandmother, also a trailblazer

    By all accounts, Madelyn Payne Dunham was a smart, no-nonsense woman who rose to the challenges life threw her way.

    Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

    MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

    One of those was helping to raise her grandson, Barack Obama, after the collapse of her daughter Ann’s marriage to a Kenyan graduate student. Less well-known is that she worked on a Boeing aircraft B-29 assembly line during World War II, and later became one of the first female vice presidents at the Bank of Hawaii.

    Last night, Barack Obama devoted his first speech as the presumptive Democratic nominee to Dunham, whom he and his half-sister call Toot” – short for “Tutu,” the Hawaiian word for grandparent.

    In his memoir, “Dreams From My Father,” Obama described his grandmother as “suspicious of overwrought sentiments or overblown claims, content with common sense.” He also called her “a trailblazer of sorts, the first woman vice-president of a local bank.”

    “What Toot believed kept her going were the needs of her grandchildren and the stoicism of her ancestors,” Obama wrote. “‘So long as you kids do well, Bar,’ she would say more than once, ‘that’s all that really matters.’ ”

    Yesterday was not the first time Obama made public mention of his grandmother, but it was the most openly sentimental.

    In his March 18th speech on race in Philadelphia, he had said he could no more disown longtime pastor Jeremiah Wright, than his own grandmother “- a woman who helped raise me, a woman who sacrificed again and again for me, a woman who loves me as much as she loves anything in this world, but a woman who once confessed her fear of black men who passed by her on the street, and who on more than one occasion has uttered racial or ethnic stereotypes that made me cringe.”

    Some criticized him for the implicit criticism of Dunham. But in a radio interview two days later, Obama said he meant no disparagement. “The point I was making was not that my grandmother harbors any racial animosity – she doesn’t,” he said. “But she is a typical white person, who, if she sees somebody on the street that she doesn’t know…there’s a reaction that’s been bred into our experiences that don’t go away and that sometimes come out in the wrong way, and that’s just the nature of race in our society.”

    Dunham, 85, has given no interviews since her grandson’s breakthrough address at the 2004 Democratic National Convention. A day after that speech, he told a Chicago Sun-Times reporter that she had called to congratulate him. “She said, ‘You did well.’ And I said, ‘Thank you.’ And she said, ‘I just kind of worry about you. I hope you keep your head on straight.’ ”

    Born Madelyn Payne in Peru, Kan., on Oct. 26, 1922, Dunham married Stanley Armour Dunham, a Baptist furniture salesman, in 1940 against the wishes of her parents, who were stern Methodists.

    As the two struggled to earn a living, they moved to California, Texas, Kansas, Washington and finally to Hawaii. Madelyn Dunham started working at the Bank of Hawaii in 1960 and was promoted to be one of the first bank female vice presidents in 1970 – no easy task in 1970s Honolulu, where both women and the minority white population were routinely discriminated against.

    “Was she ambitious? She had to be to become a vice president,” Clifford Y.J. Kong, 82, who was a senior credit officer at the bank at the time, told USA Today. “She was a top-notch executive to get appointed. It was a tough world.”

    Her colleagues at the bank recalled her as a “tough boss”, who would make you “sink or swim” but had a “soft spot for those willing to work hard.” She retired from the bank in 1986.

    Both Dunhams were reportedly upset when their daughter, Ann, marrried Barack Obama Sr., particularly after receiving a long, angry letter from the graduate student’s father in Kenya who “didn’t want the Obama blood sullied by a white woman,” according to a story in the Chicago Tribune. But they adapted.

    Obama went to live with his grandparents in Honolulu at age 10, after his mother had moved to Indonesia to be with her second husband to attend Punahou School in Honolulu. Obama writes in his memoir, “I’d arrived at an unspoken pact with my grandparents: I could live with them and they’d leave me alone so long as I kept my trouble out of sight.”

    Stanley Dunham died in 1992. Madelyn Dunham took care of her daughter Ann in Hawaii in the months before Ann died of cancer in 1995 at age 53.

    Today, Dunham lives in the same small high-rise apartment where she raised Obama, not far from his half-sister Maya Soetoro-Ng. Ng described her to USA Today as an avid bridge player, but said that these days, she mostly stays at home “listening to books on tape and watching her grandson on CNN every day.”

    .

    Click here to sign up for the Muckety Newsletter

  • Rahm Emanuel does mitzvah (finally) for Obama

    The big news out of Barack Obama’s appearance before a pro-Israel lobby group today was not his predictably strong defense of Israel, but the surprise emissary who accompanied him to make personal introductions to its board.

    Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

    MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

    The go-between with the American-Israel Public Affairs Committee was Rep. Rahm Emanuel, a fellow Chicagoan and a onetime civilian volunteer to the Israeli army and son of a Jerusalem-born pediatrician.

    Until today, Emanuel, a superdelegate, had remained uncommitted in the Democratic presidential contest because he is close with the Clintons after serving six years in Bill Clinton’s White House. “I’m hiding under the desk,” he had said as the only Democrat in Illinois’ congressional delegation who had not endorsed Obama.

    But if Emanuel didn’t step into the breach until after Obama became the presumptive Democratic nominee, his advocacy with AIPAC leaders today likely helped mollify concerns among some members that Obama may be too sympathetic to the Palestinian cause or too soft on Iran. Later, his office released a statement saying that he also endorsed Obama.

    Emanuel, the fourth-ranking Democrat in the House, is the son of Benjamin Emanuel, who worked with a Zionist paramilitary organization in Israel in the 1940s. The elder Emanuel emigrated to Chicago where he met his wife, Martha Smulevitz, an American Jew who worked as an X-ray technician.

    Before his family moved to the lakeshore suburb of Wilmette, Rahm Emanuel attended Bernard Zell Anshe Emet Day School, a Jewish high school endowed by billionaire Sam Zell. Inheriting his father’s passion for Israel, Rahm Emanuel worked as a civilian volunteer in Israel in the 1991 Gulf War, rust-proofing brakes on an army base in northern Israel.

    Beyond Emanuel’s private introduction to AIPAC’s executive board, Obama sounded all the important themes in his public remarks. He vowed to stop Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon and insisted Jerusalem will remain the undivided capital of the Jewish state.

    “Let me be clear. Israel’s security is sacrosanct. It is non-negotiable,” he said. “The Palestinians need a state that is contiguous and cohesive, and that allows them to prosper . . . But any agreement with the Palestinian people must preserve Israel’s identity as a Jewish state, with secure, recognized and defensible borders.”

    Obama got several standing ovations, including sustained applause after observing, “We must not allow the relationship between Jews and African Americans to suffer. This is a bond that must be strengthened. Together, we can rededicate ourselves to end prejudice and combat hatred in all of its forms.”

    Whether Emanuel will now act as a go-between in the tougher negotiations between Obama and Hillary Rodham Clinton remains to be seen.

  • VP vetters for McCain and Obama have had similar career paths (Muckety)

    Another sign that the Democratic presidential nomination process is over even though it’s not over: Sen. Barack Obama has chosen someone to head his vice-presidential search committee.

    Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

    MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

    James A. Johnson, a Washington insider who’s done this sort of thing before, will size up possible running mates for Obama.

    On the other side, Arthur B. Culvahouse Jr., an equally powerful inside-the-Beltway kind of guy, will coordinate the V.P. search for Sen. John McCain, the putative Republican nominee.

    Writing in Sunday’s Week in Review section of The New York Times, Jill Abramson says it’s not surprising that Obama and McCain have asked old Washington hands to take on this task even though they’re running as Washington outsiders.

    “Vetting is an extremely tricky and specialized Washington art form,” Abramson writes.

    She points out the head of the search has to organize a group whose members grill the possible candidates.

    They’ve got to “ferret out skeletons in closets, comb through finances and voting records, and try to anticipate problems that could ignite controversy in the news media.”

    Dick Cheney did this for then-Gov. George W. Bush in 2000 and settled upon himself as the vice presidential nominee.

    It would seem unlikely that either Johnson or Culvahouse would follow his example, as neither has run for elective office and each seems more comfortable behind the scenes.

    Johnson directed the vice-presidential search in 1984 for Walter Mondale, who chose Rep. Geraldine Ferraro as his running mate, and again in 2004 for John Kerry, who selected Sen. Joseph Lieberman.

    Culvahouse hasn’t headed up a vice-presidential screening, but he’s been an adviser to presidents since he was White House counsel to Ronald Reagan.

    Though they are from different political parties, Johnson, 64, and Culvahouse, 59, have quite similar career paths.

    As a younger man, each worked for a powerful Washington insider. That connection led to bigger and better things inside and outside of government.

    Johnson’s mentor and patron was Mondale, the Democratic senator from Minnesota who went on to be vice president under Jimmy Carter.

    After working for Mondale, Johnson went on to head Fannie Mae, the Federal National Mortgage Company. He was making $6 million to $7 million a year when he left the company in 1998.

    Johnson’s now on the board of Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and is vice chairman of Perseus LLC, the merchant bank and private equity fund.

    Culvahouse, a native of Tennesee, was a protege of Sen. Howard Baker of Tennesee, the former Senate majority leader.

    He served as Baker’s chief legislative assistant and counsel in the senate. And soon after Baker became Reagan’s chief of staff in 1987, Culvahouse became White House counsel.

    Culvahouse is now chair of O’Melveny & Meyers LLP, a Los Angeles law firm with offices in cities throughout the world, including Washington.

    Its partners have been involved in Democratic, as well as Republican, politics.

    Warren Christopher, the former secretary of state, is a senior partner in the firm. He headed the 2000 Florida recount effort for Democratic presidential candidate Al Gore. Ron Klain, then a partner at O’Melveny & Meyers, was general counsel to the Democratic recount effort.

    Click here to sign up for the Muckety Newsletter

  • Ted Kennedy surgery followed broad research into medical options

    Once again, Dr. Lawrence C. Horowitz is providing counsel to the Kennedy family as it confronts a medical crisis.

    Hint: Click in map to explore connectionsStory continues below interactive map 

    MAP HINTS: Click expands a name. Control+Click centers map on a name. Solid lines are current relations. Dotted lines are former relations. For advanced tools choose Tools > Options from the menu at top. More help. Not seeing the maps? Please go here to check for the latest version of Java.

    Sen. Edward M. Kennedy announced that he is having surgery today at Duke University Medical Center for his brain tumor. He will then undergo chemotherapy and radiation treatment.

    Edward M. Kennedy
    Edward M. Kennedy

    The decision followed a massive research effort led by Horowitz, a former Kennedy aide who has advised the family for more than 20 years.

    As the Boston Globe reports today, Horowitz helped the family find innovative treatments for Edward M. Kennedy Jr. when he was diagnosed with a dangerous bone cancer in his right leg. He treated Patrick Kennedy when the 12-year-old suffered an asthma attack on a airline flight. And he devised diets for Ted Kennedy when he considered a presidential run in 1984.

    Kennedy’s decision to have surgery followed an analysis by Horowitz and other former staffers, which included discussions with experts at the National Institutes of Health, the Food and Drug Administration, hospitals and pharmaceutical companies.

    “My role is to reach out to everybody everywhere – Mass. General, Brigham, anywhere across the country,” Horowitz told the Globe.

    Horowitz, a graduate of Yale Medical School, was staff director of the Senate Subcommittee on Health, chaired by Kennedy, from 1977 to 1981. He later served as Kennedy’s chief of staff.

    He is the author of Taking Charge of Your Medical Fate, about researching and assessing health care options.

    In issuing his statement this morning, Kennedy didn’t miss the opportunity to campaign for his favorite presidential candidate: “After completing treatment, I look forward to returning to the United States Senate and to doing everything I can to help elect Barack Obama as our next president,” he said.

    Click here to sign up for the Muckety Newsletter